 Understanding the silent equity loss baked into early stage fundraising. by Chris Tottman, The Founders Corner Read the entire post here. URL for this post. Until you sit down before a priced round and realise you have given away more of the company than you thought. Sometimes far more. This article is your guide to what a SAFE really is, how it converts, and how it silently reshapes your cap table. By the end, you should be able to read any SAFE term sheet and understand exactly what you are committing to, and how your ownership shifts the moment real equity appears. I have been building out a growing library of tools to help founders navigate these decisions with precision rather than instinct. New tools are released that map directly to the topics I write about. Today’s article leads into the latest addition to that library, a SAFE Dilution Calculator designed to show you the real effect your SAFEs have on your future ownership. Table of Contents 1. What A SAFE Actually Is 2. The Core SAFE Levers 3. Dilution Fundamentals You Must Know Cold 4. How SAFEs Convert In A Priced Round 5. Why SAFEs Create Surprise Dilution 6. Using SAFEs Intelligently 7. How Investors Analyse Your SAFEs 8. Bringing It All Together 9. See What This Looks Like For Your Company 1. What A SAFE Actually Is A SAFE is a Simple Agreement for Future Equity. It is not debt, there is nothing to repay. It is not equity today, there are no shares, no vote, no board presence. It is a contract that says: “You give me money now. I get equity later, when a specific fundraising event happens.”  That event is almost always your next priced round. Until that moment, the SAFE holder sits in a kind of economic shadow. They do not appear on the cap table, but the claim they hold against your future equity is very real. This is the foundation of SAFE driven dilution. The ownership does not show up until the conversion event. When it does, it lands all at once. 2. The Core SAFE Levers Everything about dilution comes down to four ideas. Valuation cap. Discount. Whether the SAFE is pre money or post money. Pro rata rights. 2.1 Valuation Cap The valuation cap is the maximum company valuation at which the SAFE converts. If your next round is priced above the cap, the SAFE converts at the cap instead. Imagine you raise at a $20,000,000 pre money valuation, but earlier you issued a SAFE with an $8,000,000 cap. That investor now converts at $8,000,000, not $20,000,000. They receive more shares than the new investor for the same dollar invested. A lot more.  2.2 Discount
A discount allows a SAFE investor to convert at a percentage below the next round price. 10%. -15%.- 20%. If the next round price per share is $1.00 and the SAFE has a 20% discount, that SAFE converts at $0.80 per share. Many SAFEs allow the investor to choose whichever is more favourable, the cap or the discount. 2.3 Pre Money versus Post Money SAFEs Pre money SAFEs often leave founders unable to calculate true dilution until conversion. Post money SAFEs allow exact ownership to be calculated immediately. For example, a $250,000 SAFE on a $6,000,000 post money valuation gives the investor 4.17% ownership. Post money SAFEs remove ambiguity, and they remove optimism. 2.4 The ASA for UK founders For founders in the United Kingdom, there is also the ASA, known as an Advanced Subscription Agreement. It plays a similar role to a SAFE but is structured to comply with SEIS and EIS rules, which makes it far more relevant for UK angels and early stage investors. The biggest functional difference is timing. An ASA typically must convert into shares within six months to remain compliant. If that conversion does not happen via a priced round within that period, the ASA usually converts at the valuation cap set out in the agreement, regardless of what the next round looks like. The mechanics feel similar to a SAFE, but the time pressure and SEIS or EIS constraints mean founders need to be more disciplined in how and when they use ASAs. 3. Dilution Fundamentals You Must Know Cold Pre money is the value of the company before the new round. Post money is pre money plus the money raised. Investors calculate ownership as: investment ÷ post money valuation Option pools complicate this because investors usually require the pool to be increased before their investment is counted, pushing that dilution onto founders and SAFE holders. Read the rest of this post here.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |